We want to know if the water on your
island is acidic or basic (alkaline).
Strongly acidic or strongly alkaline
water can be a sign of pollution and
can be harmful to plants and animals
and hazardous to drink. Carry out the
following test to check your water.
You need
a red cabbage
medium-size bowl
grater
strainer
small plastic or glass pitcher
5 clear plastic cups
baking soda
lemon juice
vinegar
cola
distilled water
“island” water (spiked with
something acidic like vinegar)
teaspoon
What you do
Grate one cup of red cabbage into a
medium-size bowl and cover it with 1/2
cup cold distilled water. Let it sit for 45
minutes. When the water turns red, strain
the cabbage juice into a plastic pitcher.
Use the cabbage juice to test for acids or
bases. Acids will make the cabbage juice
turn different shades of red, and bases
will make it turn different shades of blue.
Pour an equal amount of cabbage juice
into five plastic cups. Add 1 teaspoon of
baking soda (which is a base) to four of
the cups. The stronger the acid, the less
liquid you’ll use to get the original color
back. The fifth cup is your control. The
color of the juice in the cup with just the
baking soda is the color that you want to
get all of your mixtures to match.
Add the lemon juice, 1 teaspoon at a
time, to your first cup. How much lemon
juice did you have to add to get the
cabbage juice back to its original reddish
color? In the second cup repeat for
vinegar, and cola in the third cup. The
liquids you need to use the least of are
the most acidic. The liquids you need to
use the most of are the least acidic. The
liquids that don’t change the color at all
are bases. Now that you have a range of
reactions for comparison, test island
water in the fourth cup. What is your
conclusion? Is it acidic or basic?
What’s going on?
Red cabbage juice is an indicator. When
it comes into contact with a base, like
baking soda, it turns blue/purple. When
it’s mixed with an acid, like vinegar, it
stays red/pink. Pure water is neutral —
neither acidic nor basic.
Water can be “hard,” even
though it’s a liquid. Hard water
contains lots of minerals (such as
magnesium and calcium) that
leave deposits in pans and water
pipes. Hard water also makes it
difficult to lather up with soap.
Are you concerned about the lack
of lather when you soap up on
the island? Test your water to
see how hard it is.
You need
What you do
In the small jar mix a teaspoon of
the liquid soap with
1
/2
cup of the
distilled water to make a soap
solution. In the tall glass dissolve
1 teaspoon of Epsom salts in 2
cups of distilled water to make
hard “island” water. Pour distilled
water into one screw-top jar and
the same amount of “island”
water into the other. Use the
dropper to put one drop of soap
solution into the jar of island
water. Screw the lid on tight and
shake. If the water doesn’t foam,
add another drop of solution,
screw on the lid, and shake it
again. Repeat until the water
foams. Count how many drops of
soap solution you need. Repeat
the experiment using the screw-
top jar of distilled water. Which
water needed more drops of soap
solution to make it foam?
What’s going on?
Distilled water is “soft.” We
can use it as a measure of the
hardness—the mineral content—
of the “island water.” In hard
water the salts (magnesium and
calcium) interact with soap to
form a scum that will not form
bubbles (soap foam). Therefore,
the amount of lather is related
to the hardness of the water.
Test the Hardness of Water
“island” water
two screw-top jars
teaspoon
eye dropper
small open jar
tall drinking glass
distilled water
liquid soap
Epsom salts
measuring cup
WATER
QUALITY
CONTROL
CENTER
That tropical water really
looks inviting! Looks can
be deceiving. Before you
jump in for a swim, do a
little rough science to
check if that water’s as
pure as it looks.
The Challenges!
To determine if the
water is polluted, test
the acidity of the water.
To determine if the water
has a high or low mineral
content, test the hardness
of the water in a soap
solution.
To see what organisms
are in the water, make a
microscope.
To make sure that your
drinking water is safe,
design and build a
water filter.
Test the Acidity of Water
4 ROUGH SCIENCE • ACTIVITY GUIDE